11 Safest Places to Live on Long Island

By PropertyClub Team
May 24th 2024
When moving to Long Island, choosing a city or neighborhood with a low crime rate is important. This list of the eleven safest places to live on Long Island will help you find the safest area to call home. 

hash-mark11 Safest Places to Live in Long Island

  1. Kensington
  2. Roslyn
  3. Greenport
  4. Brookhaven
  5. Manhasset
  6. Great Neck
  7. Jericho
  8. Huntington
  9. Merrick
  10. Plainview
  11. Massapequa 

hash-mark1. Kensington 

Kensington is the safest town in Long Island. It’s a quiet village just south of Great Neck in Nassau County that’s home to 1,226 residents. Considered a bedroom community for New York City, Kensington is a family-friendly town offering good schools and low crime. The total crime rate in Kensington is 302 crimes per 100,000 residents, which is 87% lower than the national average. The violent crime rate is also 84% lower than the rest of the country, and property crime is 88% lower. That makes Kensington safer than 90% of cities in the US. 

hash-mark2. Roslyn

Roslyn is also one of the safest places to live on Long Island. This historic village sits on the island’s North Shore and has a charming small-town atmosphere that is otherwise difficult to find. The neighborhood is home to a little under 3,000 people. Roslyn is known for its blend of historical roots, remote charm, and abundant urban amenities, all of which make it one of the best places to live in Long Island

In addition to its downtown shopping and eating scene, this area is also home to several attractions, such as the Hampstead Harbor and the Robeson-Williams Grist Mill. With an overall crime rate roughly 84% below Long Island’s average, Roslyn is the ideal place to find both safety and small-town charm.  

hash-mark3. Greenport

Another one of the safest Long Island neighborhoods is Greenport. This small village is located on the island’s northern fork and was originally home to booming oyster, whaling, maritime construction, and railroad industries. But today, it is a small community of roughly 2,600 people and is a popular tourist destination. Residents of this area can relax along the water or take a leisurely stroll down one of its many boardwalks. Additional attractions in Greenport include visiting several museums, restaurants, and cafes. The crime rate of this neighborhood is about 73% below Long Island’s average, making this a peaceful option for those interested in a slow-paced lifestyle.  

hash-mark4. Brookhaven

The Town of Brookhaven is another of Long Island’s safest places to live. Located in Suffolk County, this neighborhood stretches between the island’s north and south shores and consists of nine individual villages and fifty unincorporated hamlets. In addition to local attractions such as the Brookhaven National Laboratory and Southaven County Park, this city also provides its residents with access to both the Long Island Sound and the Great South Bay. Its numerous beaches are popular among surfers, swimmers, sailors, and fishermen, making the area a popular spot among water sports enthusiasts. Crime in this area stays 69% below the Long Island average, making Brookhaven a safe choice for island dwellers. 

hash-mark5. Manhasset

In addition to being a safe area, Manhasset is also wealthy. Located on the inner segment of Manhasset Bay, this city is known for its luxury stores and high-end restaurants and has even been affectionately named “Rodeo Drive of the East Coast.” This area is popular among shoppers and food lovers, who come from all over to visit the area’s renowned shopping district, the Miracle Mile. Here, residents can find over 60 international boutiques and partake in a truly unique shopping experience. With an average home value of $1.9 million and crime rates about 65% below the island average, Manhasset is perfect for wealthy individuals and families.

hash-mark6. Great Neck

Located across from Manhasset is Great Neck, another one of the safest cities on Long Island. It’s also a great place to live for those who prefer access to Long Island’s waterfront. This area is known for its beautiful waterfront views and access to the North Shore and has even been the rumored inspiration for F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. Set away from the hustle and bustle of the inner cities, Great Neck combines laid-back living and urban amenities, making it a highly desirable area. Additionally, homebuyers here will find a variety of different architectural styles, from cute bungalows to Tudor-style homes. Finally, with a low crime rate that is 62% below the island’s average, Great Neck is a great choice for those concerned about island safety. 

hash-mark7. Jericho

Jericho is a safe place to live in Long Island that is great for those who prefer a sleepy small town. Located in the central part of Long Island, this city is situated between Hampstead and Oyster Bay and is roughly 30 miles from Manhattan. It is home to a little over 13,000 people who prefer the area for its peaceful atmosphere. The city’s exceptional school systems and family-friendly nature also make it a popular choice among young couples and families. Residents here can also take advantage of the district’s many local amenities, which include Jericho Commons, Active Kidz Long Island, Old Westbury Gardens, and more. Overall, Jericho’s crime rates are roughly 62% lower than the island’s average, making it a top choice for future and current parents. 

hash-mark8. Huntington

Huntington is another safe neighborhood to live in on Long Island’s North Shore. This city is known for its proximity to Manhattan and offers residents a quick commute into the city. A waterfront community, Huntington was originally a hub for both agriculture and shipping. But today, it is home to some of Long Island’s most beautiful beaches, marinas, parks, and harbors – all of which are major draws to the area. Other local attractions in this city include the Paramount Theatre, Oheka Castle, and the Heckscher Museum of Art. Crime rates in Huntington fall 59% below the island’s average, keeping it a safe part of the Long Island landscape. 

hash-mark9. Merrick

Merrick is one of the safest options for anyone interested in living along the island’s southern tip. Known for its beaches and great weather, this city offers its residents a suburban atmosphere while remaining close to New York City. Local attractions in this area include the Cow Meadow Preserve, Merrick Road Park, Marshall County Historical Museum, and the Memphis Zoo and Aquarium. Additionally, residents can partake in numerous seaside activities, such as fishing and swimming. Crime rates in this area remain about 58% below the island average, keeping it an ideal area for staying safe. 

hash-mark10. Plainview

Plainview is a safe area for those who prefer an active lifestyle. Located in Nassau County, this city sits about 27 miles from New York City and was originally established as a farming community. Plainview is home to about 26,000 people who appreciate the area’s variety of local parks and activity spaces. Residents here will find an abundance of tennis courts, baseball and softball fields, racquetball/handball courts, Olympic-sized pools, and more. Additionally, the area is home to several parks, such as Cantiague Park and West Hills County Park. Crime rates in this area fall 57% below the island’s average, making it an overall safe area for fitness enthusiasts. 

hash-mark11. Massapequa 

Massapequa is another one of the safest places to live in Long Island. The peaceful hamlet is located in the Town of Oyster Bay in Nassau County on the southern shore of Long Island. It’s home to 21,355 residents as of the 2020 census. Massapequa is known for its Native American roots, excellent school system, and the burger joint, “All American Massapequa,” which is a staple in Long Island. It’s also a very safe community, and the Massapequa crime rate is 1,027 incidents per 100,000 residents, which is 56% lower than the rest of the US. The violent crime rate is 45% lower than the national average, and your odds of being the victim of a crime are only 1 in 98.