Safest Neighborhoods in Milwaukee

By PropertyClub Team
Feb 5th 2024
Milwaukee boasts a vibrant culture, stunning architecture, and a dynamic lakefront. But for those considering a move, safety is often a top priority. This article delves into the thirteen safest places to live in Milwaukee County, offering a glimpse into their unique charms and highlighting the factors contributing to their security.

hash-mark13 Safest Neighborhoods In Milwaukee

  1. Bayside
  2. Fox Point
  3. North Granville
  4. River Hills
  5. Heritage Heights
  6. Clayton Crest
  7. Brookfield
  8. Alcott Park
  9. Mequon
  10. Whitefish Bay
  11. Red Oak Heights
  12. West Allis
  13. Story Hill

hash-markBayside

Bayside is a cozy, family-friendly neighborhood in Milwaukee County, known for being the safest place to live in the metropolitan area. With a population of 4,421, it stands out for having a violent crime rate that is 99% lower than the national average. Living in Bayside means you have a 1 in 175 chance of becoming a crime victim. 

While most of the village is in Milwaukee County, a small part at the end of Lake Drive bordering Fish Creek is in Ozaukee County. The residents of Bayside enjoy a secure and peaceful environment, making it an ideal place to call home.

hash-markFox Point

Fox Point is also one of the safest suburbs of Milwaukee, located in the North Shore area. With a population of 6,934, it's known for its safety, as violent crimes are 96% lower than the national average. 

Living in Fox Point, you have a 1 in 130 chance of becoming a victim of crime. The community offers shopping options like Fox Point Shops and RiverPoint Shopping Center, making it a pleasant and secure place to call home in the Milwaukee metropolitan area.

hash-markNorth Granville

North Granville is another one of the safest neighborhoods in Milwaukee. It has a population of 601 people. Living here is secure, as violent crimes are 94% lower than the national average. Your chance of becoming a victim of crime in North Granville is just 1 in 111. The median household income in this neighborhood is $42,344, making it a comfortable place to call home.

hash-markRiver Hills

River Hills is a peaceful village in Milwaukee County that has a population of 1,579 and a median age of 49.5 years. Living in River Hills comes with a low risk of crime, as violent crimes are 89% lower than the national average. You have a 1 in 424 chance of becoming a victim of violent crime in this quiet community, making it a safe and secure place to call home.

hash-markHeritage Heights

Heritage Heights is a small and peaceful community with a population of 883. Living in Heritage Heights comes with a sense of safety, as violent crimes here are 89% lower than the national average. Your chances of becoming a crime victim are 1 in 177. The median home value in Heritage Heights is $326,800, making it an affordable and secure place to call home.

hash-markClayton Crest

Nestled on the list is Clayton Crest, a small town with a population of 1,498. Here, folks can enjoy a safer environment, as violent crimes are 89% lower than the national average. With a 1 in 140 chance of becoming a victim of crime, residents feel a sense of security. 

About 1 in 20 people in Clayton Crest are Latinos, adding to the town's diversity. For outdoor activities, the community gathers at Cooper Playground, the main green space in Clayton Crest.

hash-markBrookfield

Brookfield, with a population of 41,464, is the safest suburb of Milwaukee, located approximately 10 miles from Downtown. Compared to the whole country, violent crimes in Brookfield are much lower—89% less, to be exact. Living in Brookfield, you have a 1 in 75 chance of becoming a crime victim, making it a safer place for residents.

hash-markAlcott Park

Nestled in a quiet corner, Alcott Park is a peaceful community where safety is a priority. With violent crimes a whopping 84% lower than the national average, it's a place where neighbors watch out for each other. The chance of being a victim of crime here is only 1 in 157. The homes in Alcott Park showcase a mix of ranch-style houses from the late 20th century alongside a handful of charming bungalows and Tudor-style homes. 

The median household income is just over $63,000, making it an affordable and comfortable place to call home. With a population of 1,794, Alcott Park offers a tight-knit community where everyone knows your name.

hash-markMequon

Mequon is a town in Wisconsin with a population of 25,200, making it the largest city in Ozaukee County. It's a safe place, with violent crimes being 83% lower than the national average, giving you a 1 in 118 chance of becoming a victim of crime. Half of Mequon's land is undeveloped, and agriculture plays a big role in the local economy.

hash-markWhitefish Bay

Whitefish Bay, ranked number 10 on our list of safest neighborhoods in Milwaukee, is a peaceful community with a population of 14,747. Crime rates here are impressively low, with violent crimes being 76% lower than the national average. Living in Whitefish Bay, you have a 1 in 112 chance of becoming a victim of crime. 

The village is mostly made up of single-family homes, spanning 2.4 square miles. Within this safe haven, there are around 330 businesses, contributing to the local economy and enhancing the overall quality of life for its residents.

hash-markRed Oak Heights

Next on our list of safest neighborhoods in Milwaukee is Red Oak Heights. It's a cozy neighborhood with just over 500 residents. Living here means you're in one of the safest spots, as violent crimes are 74% lower than the national average. Your chance of being a crime victim is just 1 in 210. 

Red Oak Heights also shines in wealth, ranking as the eighth wealthiest neighborhood in Milwaukee, with a median household income of a little over $66,000 per year. It's a peaceful and prosperous community, making it a great place to call home.

hash-markWest Allis

West Allis, a friendly neighborhood in Milwaukee, is home to a population of 59,484. It stands out for its safety, with violent crimes 23% lower than the national average. Living here, you have a 1 in 35 chance of becoming a victim of crime. 

The community takes pride in hosting the Wisconsin State Fair Park, featuring the iconic Milwaukee Mile, and hosting the annual Wisconsin State Fair, making West Allis a lively and engaging place to call home.

hash-markStory Hill

Story Hill, nestled in Milwaukee, completes our list of safest neighborhoods in the city. With a population of 1,805, this charming neighborhood joined Milwaukee in 1925. Most homes in Story Hill were built between 1909 and 1963, reflecting its rich history. 

What makes it stand out is its safety, as violent crimes here are 16% lower than the national average. Living in Story Hill gives you a 1 in 57 chance of falling victim to crime, making it a secure and welcoming community.